Realism vs “Fun”

One big challenge for any game in the Sports Management genre is deciding where to draw the line between trying to be as realistic as possible, and trying to make the game fun for the user.

Two key areas in Football GM were identified in which the plethora of real-life rules could confuse users to the point where they would not find the realism a positive aspect.

  • Roster Rules
  • Contract Details

Roster Rules

One of the main concerns about the real-life roster rules was the amount of designations teams can apply to players. Designations range from the “Physically Unable to Perform” list, the “Injured Reserve-Designated for Return” list to the “Reserve/Military” List.

It was decided from a very early stage that the amount of different lists would need to be curtailed.

Football GM features only one Injured Reserve list (IR) with one player per season allowed to come off it.

Players on IR

Players on IR

A player is eligible to be put on IR if the length of the injury is at least 42 days (6 weeks).

Another simplification is off-season roster rules.  For example, Future Contracts which are a staple of early year signings in real life are gone, all in the effort to make the experience more enjoyable for the user (it was felt that having to keep track of players who were due to join your team later in the year added little to the experience – in Football GM the players are signed straight away)

Contract Details

One of the features which may confuse users the most is the cap and contract rules. While the real rules have tried to be adhered to as much as possible a few things have been simplified.

The most striking aspect of contracts which has been simplified are bonus’.

In real life a player’s contract may (and likely will) include bonus’  for things ranging from number of rushing yards, to a workout bonus (if he attends off season workouts). These bonus’ are then generally split into “likely to be earned” and “not likely to be earned”, each having a different effect on the cap number.

In Football GM, in an effort to help the user keep track of the cap numbers, all these different type of bonus’ have been merged into one*; A yearly Roster Bonus. If a player is on the roster on the date his bonus is due, he will get  the money.

Upcoming dates for when Player's Bonus' are due.

Upcoming dates for when Player’s Bonus’ are due.

The home screen will display all important upcoming dates so the user will know when these bonus’ are due.

On each player’s contract panel, Football GM will try and explain to the user what the terms of a contract mean, and explain any rules.

Explanation of rules (in a early stage of development)

Explanation of rules (in a early stage of development)

Releasing Mark Sanchez?

Releasing Mark Sanchez?

The texts in the explanations will be looked at on  a regular basis – as well as if there is a need to explain any other rules –  as there is a thin line between not providing enough information to the user and annoying the user by swamping them with too much explanation.

*From the point of view of the Data, all real life bonuses deemed “likely to be earned” have been merged into the roster bonus. This way it is felt that Football GM still keeps the realistic contract/cap amounts, while being able to get rid of all the other bonuses.

Want to see a future article about something in particular? Feel free to leave us a comment below!


3 thoughts on “Realism vs “Fun”

    • Yes, maybe options in the future would be the best route to go.
      It’s very hard between trying to keep it easier for the user but also not over-simplifying things.

      • Exactly, that’s the problem. As I’ve said any number of times (probably in many more words) on the Out Of The Park Baseball forums (I’m Cryomaniac there) I think the end point has got to be as close to complete realism as possible, even if most people don’t actually play with totally realistic options.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s